Understanding and Resolving Kernel Deadlocks in Linux: A Deep Dive into the ‘Sleeping While Atomic’ Race Condition

By /

Introduction to the ‘Sleeping While Atomic’ Kernel Deadlock

The ‘Sleeping While Atomic’ kernel deadlock is a critical issue in Linux kernel development, occurring when a function that sleeps (e.g., kmalloc() with GFP_KERNEL) is called from an atomic context, such as within a spinlock-protected section. This violation of kernel synchronization rules leads to system instability, panic messages, or indefinite hangs, requiring precise diagnosis and resolution.

Symptoms of the Deadlock

Common symptoms include:

  • BUG: sleeping function called from invalid context panic messages in kernel logs.
  • System freezes during high-load scenarios, with no traceable user-space process.
  • Stack traces in dmesg pointing to functions like __alloc_pages() or kmalloc() invoked from atomic contexts.
  • Unresponsive kernel threads or deadlocks in critical sections.

Root Cause Analysis

Inappropriate Synchronization Primitives

The root cause lies in the misuse of memory allocation functions within atomic contexts. The Linux kernel enforces strict rules for synchronization: spinlocks are non-blocking, while mutexs or semaphores allow sleeping. When a function like kmalloc(GFP_KERNEL) (which may sleep) is called while holding a spinlock, it violates these rules. The kernel’s lockdep subsystem detects this, but the validation might not always trigger before a panic.

Example of Faulty Code

Consider the following snippet:


spinlock_t my_lock;
void faulty_function() {
spin_lock(&my_lock);
char *buffer = kmalloc(1024, GFP_KERNEL); // Sleeps if memory is low
if (buffer) {
// ... use buffer
kfree(buffer);
}
spin_unlock(&my_lock);
}

This code improperly allocates memory while holding a spinlock, risking preemption and deadlocks.

Diagnosis Tools and Techniques

Kernel Logs and dmesg

Use dmesg to identify the panic message. For example:


BUG: sleeping function called from invalid context at kernel/sched.c:1234

This message highlights the function call’s invalid context.

lockdep and perf

lockdep checks for lock usage violations. Enable it via CONFIG_DEBUG_LOCKDEP and analyze output for atomic context leaks. perf can trace function calls and memory allocations during the issue’s occurrence.

debugfs and slabtop

Inspect slab cache behavior with slabtop to identify memory allocation patterns. debugfs provides access to low-level kernel debugging interfaces, including lock statistics.

Step-by-Step Resolution Strategy

1. Reproduce the Issue

Trigger the deadlock by simulating high memory pressure (e.g., using stress-ng) or reproducing the workload that causes the atomic context to call a sleeping function.

2. Analyze Kernel Logs

Use dmesg | grep -i 'bug' to locate the exact line in the kernel source where the violation occurs. Example output:


[12345.67890] Pid: 1234, comm: my_kernel_module Tainted: GF...
[12345.67890] Call Trace:
[12345.67890] __alloc_pages+0x123/0x456
[12345.67890] kmalloc+0x78/0x90
[12345.67890] faulty_function+0x45/0x67

3. Identify Atomic Contexts

Search kernel source files for spinlocks, spin_lock(), or spin_trylock() in the affected module. Tools like grep -r 'spin_lock' /usr/src/linux can locate relevant code.

4. Refactor the Code

Replace GFP_KERNEL with GFP_ATOMIC in the allocation call to ensure it does not sleep:


char *buffer = kmalloc(1024, GFP_ATOMIC);

If memory allocation must sleep, release the spinlock before calling kmalloc(), then reacquire it afterward.

5. Validate with lockdep

Recompile the kernel with CONFIG_DEBUG_LOCKDEP enabled and monitor for warnings. A clean build ensures no invalid lock usage remains.

6. Test and Monitor

After patching, use perf and slabtop to confirm stable memory allocation patterns. Repeat the workload to ensure the deadlock is resolved.

Conclusion

The ‘Sleeping While Atomic’ deadlock underscores the importance of strict synchronization practices in kernel development. By leveraging tools like dmesg, lockdep, and careful code review, developers can preemptively identify and resolve such issues, ensuring system stability and performance.

Scroll to Top